Smokey Robinson’s legal battle took a new turn this week after a judge dismissed key claims filed by the Motown legend and his wife.
According to court documents, a Los Angeles judge ruled that there was insufficient evidence to support the couple’s defamation allegations against four former employees and their attorney. The Robinsons had accused the women of making false public statements, including calling the singer a “serial and sick rapist” during a press conference.
In the ruling, the judge said the evidence presented did not meet the required legal standard. “The evidence of actual malice does not approach the clear and convincing standard,” the judge stated.
The dismissal is tied to California’s Anti-SLAPP law, which protects individuals from lawsuits that target speech on matters of public concern.
An attorney for the women welcomed the decision, calling it “a powerful and unequivocal victory” and arguing the countersuit was meant to intimidate them.
Robinson’s legal team disagreed with the outcome. His attorney said, “There is plenty of evidence of actual malice,” adding that the case will continue to focus on disputing the underlying allegations.
The four women previously accused Robinson of sexual assault in a separate filing, which he has denied.
Additional claims brought by Robinson, including allegations involving evidence and property, remain pending as the case progresses.
